2028 WC HOTY Award

[Buane]

Please vote!

[jadacormier]

That's nice of you to not include Terraboa since he'd split the vote with Martinez, thus guaranteeing a Zarate win.

EDIT: In all seriousness, how are Terraboa and Summers not included in this poll?

[tadashi]

Voting for the guy worth over 7 WAR in just 113 games. Hell of a season by Najera.

[McExpos]

A CF who should be a LF, a LF who should be a 1B, and a SS who uses Matt Goff's trainer. Na... Najera?

[jadacormier]

A CF who should be a LF, a LF who should be a 1B, and a SS who uses Matt Goff's trainer. Na... Najera?

So you won't vote for Muldoon because he missed a quarter of the season, but Najera gets a pass?

[McExpos]

So you won't vote for Muldoon because he missed a quarter of the season, but Najera gets a pass?

Najera has calming eyes.

[Felix]

As per the norm, this thread/poll is a joke.

[aceman034]

As per the norm, this thread/poll is a joke.

Yup. Terror or summers would have been right there with zarate.

[Felix]

I don't even care about Terror, but anyone that votes for a player that literally.. LITERALLY missed over 30% of the season is wrong. I don't care how good he was when he was healthy.

[Buane]

Summers played more than half his season in the East or are people forgetting that?

Also, Najera missed almost one third of the season. I don't care how high your OOTP WAR is, I'm not voting for you when your peers played that much more than you did.

[McExpos]

I was secretly hoping that Summers would win MVP in the WC and LeClair would win MVP in the EC, then I could bask in all my second-hand accolades.

[Felix]

Also, Najera missed almost one third of the season. I don't care how high your OOTP WAR is, I'm not voting for you when your peers played that much more than you did.

Anyone that votes for Najera just doesn't give a shit about these awards, and that's a real shame.

[tadashi]

Yes, I'm actually saying I think that 2/3 of a season from Najera was worth more than all of what Zarate played. Especially considering Zarate was in center field for 129 games. And I do care about these awards. I was mostly kidding about WAR, since we all know it's broken, but it's not crazy to think that Najera could have had the best year of his career in the final season of his "peak" years. Even if I thought another 40 games would pull Najera down around Zarate's OPS, I'd give the tie-breaker to Najera for his defense. Najera would also have probably easily hit as many or more home runs than Zarate and Najera's road split was phenomenal, so when I start splitting hairs, I still tilt for Najera.



I can't believe everybody's against me in the one time I'm totally down for Najera.